One of the questions before the tribunal was whether it had the jurisdiction to declare that the british occupation of the chagos archipelago and the forcible removal of the. Introduction in the recent case of chagos marine protected area,1 a fivemember tribunal constituted under the united nations convention on the law of the sea unclos 2 held in its hands the fate of the chagos archipelago. Suriname, and mv virginia g9 the mv saiga line of cases effectively invoked article 2931 to expand their jurisdiction. Paragraph 1 of article 288 provides that a court or. International character of the secretariat 90 article 169. Unclosii territorial waters exclusive economic zone. Pdf the order of the unclos annex vii arbitral tribunal. United nations convention on the law of the sea contents page. The philippines urged the tribunal to adopt this latter view in south china sea in assessing the impact of different bilateral and multilateral agreements and treaties as alternative dispute settlement regimes to unclos arbitration or adjudication. Article 281 the procedures in part xv unclos apply only where the. See contentious jurisdiction article 297 of unclos and declarations under article 298 of unclos.
Article 287, part xv settlement of disputes click on part xv in the left index column. Delimitation as an exception to the unclos compulsory dispute. Louis b sohn, peaceful settlement of disputes in ocean conflicts. The vicissitudes of dispute settlement under the law of the. This point seems to have been implicit in judge nelsons separate opinion in the mox plant case ireland v. Jurisdiction of international courts and tribunals.
Article 281 privileges previous bilaterally agreedon disputeresolution mechanisms over those contained in unclos, while article 298 allows states parties to opt out of certain resolution mechanisms. It should also be noted that the intricacies of the canadian and rus. The sovereignty of a state extends to a belt of sea adjacent to its coast, described as the territorial sea. Unclos united nations convention on the law of the sea.
Unclos marine environment article 192 general obligation states have the obligation to protect and preserve the marine environment. Part xv of the 1982 united nations convention on the law of the sea unclos establishes a comprehensive system for the settlement of disputes that might arise with respect to the interpretation and application of unclos. On the other hand, the tribunals in mox plant,10 chagos, arctic sunrise,12 and 5. Introduction in the recent case of chagos marine protected area,1 a fivemember tribunal constituted under the united nations convention on the law of the sea unclos2 held in its hands the fate of the chagos archipelago. This article discusses the issue of treaty regimes in parallel to the united nations convention on the law of the sea in respect of peaceful settlement of disputes. The united nations convention on law of the sea unclos divides the sea floor into zones, one of which, the juridical continental shelf, only comes into existence if it is claimed by a coastal state. The philippines renounces war as an instrument of national policy, adopts the generally accepted principles of international law as part of the law of the land and adheres to the policy of peace. Convention on the law of the sea unclos was a key part of the sinophilippine arbitration on the south china sea award issued in july 2016. If the states parties which are parties to a dispute concerning the interpretation or application of this convention have agreed to seek settlement of the dispute by a. Procedure where no settlement has been reached by the parties.
United nations convention on the law of the sea unclos montego bay, 10 december 1982 preamble part i. This paper will analyze the specific legal regime in part v of unclos to determine whether it has created a certain and predictable regime which has withstood the test of time. Settlement of disputes under unclos law of the sea and. Article 76 of unclos defines the continental shelf in a complex and possibly contradictory manner, one that. The united nations convention on the law of the sea unclos is an international treaty which was adopted and signed in 1982. The key provisions were article 281 of unclos and article 16 of the ccsbt. Note that the absence of a dispute as to the interpretation or application of the convention may mean that a tribunal may not have to inquire further as to whether other preconditions to. United nations convention on the law of the sea preamble and excerpts from part xii summary.
This sovereignty is exercised subject to the conditions prescribed in these articles and by other rules of international law. Article 193 sovereign right of states to exploit their natural resources states have the sovereign right to exploit their natural resources pursuant to their environmental policies. It replaced the four geneva conventions of april, 1958, which respectively concerned the territorial sea and the contiguous zone, the continental shelf, the high seas, fishing and conservation of living resources on the high seas. Pdf the interpretation of article 281 of unclos in a recent. It replaced the four geneva conventions of april, 1958, which respectively concerned the territorial sea and the contiguous zone, the continental shelf, the high seas, fishing and conservation of living resources on the. This article uses the principles of treaty interpretation codified in article 31 of the 1969 vienna convention on the law of treaties to evaluate the. Significance and limits of the enhanced compulsory jurisdiction of international courts and tribunals article 281of unclos procedure where no settlement has been reached by the parties 1. Yale law journal jurisdiction and applicable law under unclos. Mixed disputes under the dispute settlement procedures of. Articles concerning the law of the sea with commentaries, 1956. Disputes between states on issues of law of the sea cannot be resolved by a court or tribunal unless both states consent modes of consent. Significance and limits of the enhanced compulsory. Exception to unclos jurisdiction under article 281 1 article 281 1 may offer an exception to unclos compulsory dispute settlement procedures.
According to australias view, unless and until a decision. If the states parties which are parties to a dispute concerning the interpretation or application of this convention. The vicissitudes of unclos dispute settlement 335 section 1 of part xv article 281 the losc dispute settlement regime sits within our general requirements to settle disputes peacefully under international law. If the states parties which are parties to a dispute concerning the interpretation or application of this. This work is excerpted from an official document of the united nations. The law of the sea convention defines the rights and responsibilities of nations with. The juridical continental shelf of a coastal state comprises the submerged natural prolongation of its land territory, and consists of the seabed and. Article 287, paragraph 1, provides that states and entities, when signing, ratifying or acceding to the convention, or at any time thereafter, may make declarations specifying the forums for the settlement of disputes which they accept. September 2016, unclos tribunals in seven cases have considered whether article 2931 can expand their jurisdiction. Precluding the applicability of section 2 of part xv of the. The coastal state may adopt laws and regulations, in conformity with the provisions of this convention and other rules of international law, relating to innocent passage through the territorial sea, in respect of all or any of the following.
Article 1943 importantly lists as under its control these installations and devices used in exploration or exploitation of the natural resources of the seabed and subsoil, 44 unclos, supra note 18, art. Unclos, declares that in accepting the provisions of part iv of article 47 of the said convention, wishes to highlight its concerns relating to the formula used for drawing archipelagic baselines. Ospar convention, and relevant under article 2818or article 2829unclos. The policy of this organisation is to keep most of its documents in the public domain in order to disseminate as widely as possible the ideas contained in the united nations publications. Itlospress 281 24 april 2019 international tribunal. Commentary 1 paragraph 1 brings out the fact that the rights. Itlospress 281 24 april 2019 international tribunal for the. If the states parties which are parties to a dispute concerning the. The effect of this provision upon the commencement of part xv, section 2 procedures is similar to that of article 281.
Precluding the applicability of section 2 of part xv of. It is the only alternative by which we can hope to avoid the escalating tension that will be inevitable if the present situation is allowed to. Unclos establishes the commission on the limits of the continental shelf clcs to whom claims are to be submitted for comment. Sharing benefits arising from the exploitation of mineral resources of the deep seabed between developed and developing countries is one of the main goals of the united nations convention on the law of the sea unclos says professor tullio scovazzi, professor of international law at the university of milanobicocca, milan italy and one of italys most renown experts on unclos. If the state parties whichare parties to a disputeconcerning the. The order of the unclos annex vii arbitral tribunal to suspend proceedings in the case of the mox plant at sella field. The united nations convention on the law of the sea unclos, also called the law of the sea convention or the law of the sea treaty, is the international agreement that resulted from the third united nations conference on the law of the sea unclos iii, which took place between 1973 and 1982. Optional clause declaration under article 36 of the icj statute 3. The provisions of this part apply to all parts of the sea that are not included in the exclusive economic zone, in the territorial sea or in the internal waters of a state, or in the archipelagic waters of an archipelagic state. The interpretation of article 281 of unclos in a recent international arbitral award.
Source document contributed to documentcloud by will colson center for strategic and international studies. Article 287, part xv, of the united nations convention on the law of the sea provides that when signing, ratifying or acceding to this convention or at any time thereafter, a state shall be free to choose, by means of a written declaration, one or more of the following means for the settlement of. The obligations to exercise selfrestraint and cooperate under unclos. The award demonstrates that a hotly contested dispute can be settled in accordance with international law, but it also shows the limits of what arbitration can achieve based on. The tribunal has jurisdiction over all disputes concerning the interpretation or application of the convention, subject to the provisions of article 297 and to the declarations made in accordance with article 298 of the convention. Procedure where no settlement has been reached by the parties article 282. Legal status of the territorial sea, of the air space over the territorial sea and of its bed and. Section 1 of part xv recognizes that states have a wide choice of means in determining how they will. Article 4 of cmats and articles 281 and 298 of unclos. The basis for this consideration was article 2811 of unclos which provides. Article 281 procedurewhereno settlementhasbeen reachedby theparties 1. Legal status of the territorial sea, of the air space over the territorial sea and of its bed and subsoil.
The rule of law in the seas of asia navigational chart for. Article 281 allows parties to the convention by agreement between them to opt out of compulsory and binding dispute resolution. This article examines the jurisprudence that has arisen with respect to articles 281 283 of section 1 of part xv. One of the questions before the tribunal was whether it had the jurisdiction to declare that the british occupation of the chagos archipelago and the. Part iv calculations for archipelagic waters do not allow a baseline to be drawn around all the islands of each of the three groups of islands that. Article 281 1 provides that if the parties to a dispute have agreed to seek settlement of the dispute by a peaceful means of their own choice, the mandatory arbitration. Pdf the order of the unclos annex vii arbitral tribunal to. Settlement of disputes by any peaceful means chosen by the parties. Some reflections on the southern bluefin tuna case. The effect of article 281 on disputes which are the subject of an article 298 exception is that if there is a 281 agreement in place between the parties and it does exclude further procedures, then the procedures in part xv will not apply to the settlement of the dispute. Pardo ended with a call for an effective international regime over the seabed and the ocean floor beyond a learly defined national jurisdiction. The vicissitudes of dispute settlement under the law of.
Made an article 298 declaration in 2002, excluding maritime delimitation disputes from unclos binding procedures. Climate change and the use of the dispute settlement regime of the law of the sea convention. Settlement of disputes under unclos law of the sea and the. Article 281, paragraph 1 of unclos article 16 of ccsbt 3 1.
Pdf climate change and the use of the dispute settlement. The word was also exposed to criticism for broadening the scope of compulsory jurisdiction on their unclos through its interpretation of article 281 of the convention. Laws and regulations of the coastal state relating to innocent passage 1. Other arcticrelated issues that are not directly related to this jurisdictional relationship will therefore not be discussed in this thesis. The rule of law in the seas of asia navigational chart. The united nations describes its 1982 convention on the law of the sea unclos as possibly the most signi. Timor sea conciliation under article 298 and annex v of. If the states parties which are parties to a dispute concerning the interpretation or application of this convention have agreed to seek settlement of the dispute by a peaceful means of their own choice, the procedures provided for in this part apply only where no settlement. If the states parties which are parties to a dispute concerning the interpretation. Article 281 of unclos procedure where no settlement has been reached by the parties provides that. United nations convention on the law of the sea unclos. It should be noted that mauritius on the surface argued that article 2931 does not expand the jurisdiction of unclos tribunals.
Legal status of the territorial sea, of the air space over the territorial. Entered into force 16 november 1994 unclos entered into force between 2 states on 2 february 20. Article 76 of unclos defines the continental shelf in a complex and possibly contradictory manner, one that seemingly requires a great deal of data and scientific analysis. Osp ar convention, and relevant under article 281 8 or article 282 9 unclos, did not substantially cover the present dispute or alter its nature. Provides a detailed introduction to the negotiations, a history of sessions from 19731982, documentation citations and, on the last page, a law of the sea chronology. Unclos and article 76 the united nations convention on the law of the sea unclos defines the different maritime zones and regulates marine sovereignty rights and rights of use, among others. Reflections after 30 years robert beckman and tara davenport1 abstract. United nations convention on the law of the sea contents. Nonapplicability of articles 69 and 70 48 article 72. Article 193 sovereign right of states to exploit their natural resources. Settlement of disputes article 281 procedure where no settlement has been reached by the parties 1.
1154 1211 1229 902 1112 993 1192 1151 1275 226 1528 724 1523 1172 1267 989 710 422 53 1455 181 1305 8 913 302 873 268 267 245 1522 316 1488 479 601 888 295 388 880 25 967 446 1402 874